Appearance: Andrew is a scrawny scrap of a thirteen-year-old. He is bone-thin, lacking the muscles of a Quidditch player and the roundness of a child. Only his head seems unaffected by this--his face is still baby-round, with a pointy chin. He stands at almost five feet tall and is characterized by his customary stare at the ground beneath his feet. His body is mostly of average proportions, except for his head which seems to be too big on his shoulders. He has fingers that are too long, sticks that pass for legs, and knobby knees. Never in his life was he ever satisfied with his own appearance, and he probably never will be. Overall, a nice paragraph. In the first sentence you say he lacks the roundness of a child but then in the second mentions he still has a round, baby face. When I first read roundness of a child I immediately thought of the face so it threw me for a loop, but that just might be me. Going off of that, when you say baby-round do you mean round in the baby fat sense or that his head is just very circular and doesn’t seem to have the matured, distinct features. I hope that made sense. Also, I’d like to see expansion of each of the body sections. My advice is start your own body and go from head to toe. I think it also makes it an easier read for people because they can visualize that one area better instead of thinking about the head then going to the legs then back up for the hair, but that’s a personal preference. It’ll also help you think about what you’re missing: forehead, eyebrows, eyes, nose, cheeks, ears... so on and so forth. Basically, use your own body as a checklist. Another place I’d like to see another sentence or two, and this could arguably fit better in personality but I’d say stick it in here, is the last sentence about him not liking his body. Why? Sure, he’s pretty scrappy and odd but what it is specifically that he’s uncomfortable. Most people have a weakness, something that they are really physically self-conscious about above the rest of the body.
Most clothes don't fit him at all, so he doesn't bother with looking for the right ones How do his clothes fit him? Why don’t they fit? Is it his big head? Is he too short for his pants? Especially since you mentioned sentence four of paragraph one that he is averagely proportionate aside from his head and to mean average means his clothes should fit. Also, what kind of clothes does he end up wearing? Do all of his cltohes have to come custom made? Does he wear them big and drown in them or does he wear them short and show an inch of sock?. A peculiarity of his is that he is mostly unaffected by the weather. In a blizzard he would be numb to the cold and wear only a sweater--in blazing summer heat he would be able to wear the same and not feel anything different. Supposedly, when he was a child, this was how his parents found out he had magic.I do that.... does that mean I’m magic?! Sorry, that has nothing to do with anything. I just really want to be magical. He likes to wear blue, not so much because he loves Ravenclaw, but more because most of his clothes are the same color as his eyes--which, if you haven't deduced, are blue. *chuckle* Sneakers in any weather suit him just fine, as well as jeans or khakis when he isn't swamped in his school robes. In fact, his Hogwarts robes nearly drown him during the school day, and he is always modifying it, but he hasn't quite gotten the hang of that yet. Again, I really have little to say other than expand. What he wears is a statement of who he is. Aside from clothes, does he have any accessories he always has? A special bookbag, a favorite tie, a hidden tattoo ;). Flow-wise, something from the unaffected by weather statement to the end isn’t sitting well with me. I’d prefer that the sneakers comment and following sentences not be so separated from the initial “weather does not dictate what he wears” idea. But I do like the comments in between so I’m not saying chuck them. Just to experiment, move things around. Maybe mention first off that his parents suspected something when his outfits did not seem to change witht he varying weather and then go into the always wearing sweaters and sneakers and such. Again, I like what you have. Just expand..
His skin is the softest of soft, and paler than a ghost's. During his early childhood he rarely saw sunlight, so he tends to have the appearance of just recovering from a long illness. Ew, why? Def have that in the history if it isn’t already when you get around to revising that part because I’m curious.. In recent years his complexion has improved slightly...but only slightly. Improved from what? What did his acne used to be like? Complete craterface or just moderate breakouts here and there... how often, how bad and how is it different now. Perhaps in years to come he might even end up looking like a normal child--a small possibility, but one nevertheless. His face is round, except for a thin, pointy chin. Repeated from the first paragraph, I personally say chuck the previous sentence since we already know. He has an impish smile and eyebrows that can do the wave. Andrew's eyes are the cleanest of blues, but they usually lack the sparkle of people his age and are dulled. I don’t like the dulled. Maybe if instead of ‘and are’ you used ‘but instead appear dull’ but I don’t know. I feel like the lack the sparkle was sufficient. His nose is thin and pointed, and his mouth is too pink in his face--and his lips are so thin that they might as well not exist. Again, with flow. I personally like to see all the areas kept together so I’d like this better up where you first went into detail about the shape of his head.
His hair is light brown. It's quite long, and messy enough to give his mother a headache. Being someone who doesn't worry too much about appearances, Andrew leaves his hair alone. Entirely alone? Like just rolls out of bed alone? Or just combs it out hastily and is done? Is it messy? Does his mom do his hair in any way? I got the sense that if it gives her a headache she must cut it for him or something.. He stays away from gel and dyes--and potions that change his hair color according to mood. Why? Is it because he thinks it’s shallow? Is he afraid what his hair color might betray about his mood?. The only time he'll think about his hair is when he gets a haircut. Since he plays a lot of Quidditch, twigs tend to get stuck in his hair--twigs, dry leaves, bits of grass, etc. Generally, aside from him pallor, Andrew is a normal scrawny boy thrust into his teens without quite realizing it.
Personality: Who is the clumsiest boy at Hogwarts? Doubtless, the honor would go to Andrew here, who trips over everything, from rocks to blades of grass to thin air. Part of me would like to see this into two sentences.. His fingers, though long and slender, are clumsy; his feet are the bane of his existence. Perhaps for this reason he is quite taken with Quidditch--indeed, he is unusually good at it for a boy his age. And despite his build, you can through that in there if you want. He certainly won't be a match for an older, seasoned athlete, but he is able to hold his own on the pitch. Quidditch is his passion, and one of the driving forces that keep him going. The walls of his dorm are covered with Quidditch posters (mostly of the Arrows, his favorite team) and the space under his bed is occupied by stacks of slightly dusty chronicles of the game. What’s his favorite position? How did he get into Quidditch? Is it natural talent or the result of lots of hardwork?
Aside from Quidditch, he loves to read. Most of his time indoors is spent inside the great library of Hogwarts, where he likes to bury his nose in various types of books. Recently he's taken a liking to the Restricted section, and he's gotten very good at sneaking off there when no one is paying attention. Most of his reading, though, is centered on the history of the wizarding world--historical fiction being his favorite genre--and stories about Muggles. He finds Muggles to be a very interesting subject, but he prefers to learn about both Muggle life and History of Magic on his own time. Anything, in his mind, is better than the drone of the boring professors who teach both. Is there a deep-rooted psychological reason that he enjoys reading? Lol, sorry. Would he rather read or hand out with people? Is he introverted? Would he rather read or play Quidditch?.
Andrew tends to have a shorter attention span than most Ravenclaws, hence the reason he can't focus in class. How short? 3 second goldfish short? Why? Is it because he has high anxiety and can’t focus because he’s stressed? Is he just really hyper and can’t sit still? Is he a daydreamer? In what way is he not focusing? Even so, he manages to maintain Ravenclaw-level grades due to the time he spends reading outside of the classroom. He is very curious, having been, for lack of a better word, sheltered as a younger child. Sometimes he ponders why he ended up in Ravenclaw, lacking most of the traditional traits of the house--level-headedness, cunning, competition, among others--and his conclusion is that his thirst for knowledge is stronger than all of his other traits.
Although generally a mild-mannered, calm person, he is very flustered when he causes a commotion. This happens when he trips over things--his face burns scarlet; he apologizes until he runs out of breath. In fact, when he isn't happily wondering around in his own air-headed world, he's staring at the carpet, face smoking, apologies streaming out of his mouth. Most people at Hogwarts give him a wide berth because they don't have the time to deal with him and his liking for laying the blame on himself. Actually, Andrew just has very low self-esteem, instead of the calm self-assurance so closely associated with Ravenclaw. Sometimes it comes off as pitiful; most of the time, it's just annoying. Don’t have much to say here. Other than whether or not you want to go into his flustered reactions with the classic ears burning, thumb twiddling, rocking back and forth... stereotypical behavior. Also, where does his insecurity come from? People are insecure for a reason. And what is he most unsure of himself for? His looks, his personality, the whole package? Is it because his parents are too hard on him? Because he gets picked on a lot in school?
One thing about him is dangerous, though: when his temper finally ignites, he is possibly fatal to everyone around him. Of course, he can't actually kill people, but when he's angry he tends to throw around some nasty hexes at whoever is within firing range. Only issue is the use of fatal. Fatal = deadly so if he’s not actually killing anybody I’d go with a different adjective. I can’t think of one off the top of my head... sorry >.< It takes a lot--a lot--to make Andrew really angry, but it also takes a lot to calm him down. He doesn't like getting mad, for obvious reasons, so his temper rarely ever flares up even if people repeatedly bash him on the head with a rock. No one really knows what makes him so angry. He doesn't really know himself. However, the silver lining is that he's unlikely to develop in a bad way! But what are some circumstances when his temper has flared? Has he ever done something during such times that he really regrets? Maybe is the reason why he gets flustered when he is clumsy and bumps into people? Because he might be afraid it will lead to something where he can’t control his anger? Also, what does it take to calm him down. You say a lot, but it is something he has to do alone or does he need a friend? What is his outlet? Or is it just that his rage burns for so long it eventually fizzles?
All in all, I really do like what you have. I like the kind of cheeky, funny undertone of the whole thing. All I have to say is just keep expanding, adding as you learn more about the person you want to be. For appearance, do the down your body checklist. For personality, put Andrew on the imaginary therapist chair. My only issue there is you run into what should be in the history section versus personality. I’ve always struggled with that. But overall, very nice ^^ Hope I helped, my brain is still on the fritz
I know you want us to tear apart the history, but ... Lily, that is one of the best damn histories I've read in a while! It was so sad, and yet really happy. I want him to continue to hear Mikey ... but I can imagine why he wouldn't want to. What I would suggest is to expand a little bit more on Andrew and Michael's relationship with each other - you've done well explaining how he felt jealous of him, and ignored by his parents, but there isn't a lot explained about their relationship with each other. Other than that, you have a very detailed History here, miss. I'm impressed ^_^
Now, for the rest of your profile. My edits will be in the big, bold, pen of slytherin. Mmkay?
| QUOTE |
Andrew is a scrawny scrap of a thirteen-year-old, a doll-like child1. He is thin and frail, lacking the muscles of a Quidditch player and the roundness of a child. Only his head seems unaffected by this—his face is still baby-round, with a pointy chin.2 He stands at almost —almost five feet tall, and is characterized by his customary stare at the ground beneath his feet. His body is mostly of average proportions, except for his head which seems to be too big on his shoulders. When he’s not out playing Quidditch, he is usually hunched over, studying the floor tile pattern or watching his feet—bad posture sticks to him like a permanent sticking charm.3 Never in his life was Andrew ever satisfied with his own appearance, and he probably never will be. In the mirror he sees a frail, weak child—in his mind he aspires to be strong and well.4 |
1 What do you mean by "doll-like?" Explain.
2 I don't really understand this statement. Only his head seems unaffected by what? The fact that he doesn't have quidditch muscles or roundness of a child? So his head is muscular and round? O.o
3 The "—" doesn't really make sense in this sentence. I think you should change it to something like this:
"... or watching his feet, which causes bad posture to stick to him like a permanent sticking charm."
Nice metaphor, by the way!
4 Once again, I would replace the "—" with the word "but." Don't use too many of those—it can get confusing real easily.
| QUOTE |
| To begin at the top—his hair is light brown.1 It's quite long, and messy enough to give his mother a headache. Being someone who doesn't worry too much about appearances, Andrew leaves his hair alone. He stays away from gel and dyes--and potions that change his hair color according to mood.2 Once upon a time, he tried the latter, only to have the solution turn his locks a perpetual shade of shy pink. From then on he learned his lesson and never messed with his hair again. The only time he'll think about his hair is when he gets a haircut—a squeamish ritual that has him fidgeting in his chair while his mother attacks it with enchanted scissors.3 It’s fair to say that Andrew walks around with bits of leaves and grass in his hair—the only indication about his appearance that he isn’t a sickly child who needs breakfast brought to him in bed.4 |
1 I would change the first sentence. I don't like the "to start at the top" part too much. Don't know why -shrug-
2 Lily. Stop using "—" too much. xD Most of the time, you can connect the two sentences with a word. Usually, a "—" is used to add something as more of an afterthought, or a side note. For example:
Evan walked down the stairs, being sure to skip the second step — he had fallen through it once before, and never wanted to repeat it — before he came to a halt at the bottom of the flight.
It was used in that case to add more of a side note, or to give the reader a glimpse into
why he skipped the step. So if you're going to use this, you'd have to change it to something along the lines of this:
He stays away from gel, hair dyes, and colour-changing potions — he tried the latter once before, only to have the solution turn his locks a perpetual shade of shy pink.
That's the proper way to use them, but try and avoid them if you can. ^_^
3 Yes! That's how you use them!
4 Wrong again! I would replace "—" with "... and grass in his hair,
which is the only indication ..."
The rest is fine, with a few more "—" errors. That's the one thing I want you to work on - try avoiding "—"'s as much as you can. Usually connecting words work just as well, though I can see what you're trying to do. Keep up the good work, Lilypants!